Answering some questions

Some time ago, Adity Sharma had asked me some questions via email. Adity is a student at St. John’s University School of Law in New York. Here are her questions and my answers which she first published in Chakranews:

What was originally planned as a trip to see Kerala’s wildlife, transmuted into a journey of spiritual discovery for Maria Wirth. She writes in her
BLOG about Hindu Dharma with clarity, deep insight and yet in simple language. It shows that hers is not merely abstract knowledge but based on experience and intuition.

Adity Sharma (AS): You have written at some length in your blog about your conversion to Hinduism. But there have been quite a few pagan revivals in many parts of Europe. Even in the Middle East, many pagan tribes have struggled to hold onto their tradition.
What drew you to Hinduism in particular?

Maria Wirth (MW): I was not in search of a religion. I had lost faith in Christianity when I was about 16, but a vague feeling that there may be an invisible, great power never left me. When I discovered Vedanta philosophy in India, it was like recognizing a truth that felt immensely familiar. It made immediately sense, though I could not have expressed it on my own. I did not think that I had found a ‘religion’, but that I had come closer to truth.

Pagan traditions in Europe cannot be compared to Hindu tradition. When Christianity rolled over Europe, it destroyed them thoroughly. When neo Pagans today reinvent ancient rituals, worship nature and the divine feminine, it seems somewhat artificial to me as a solid, philosophical basis is lacking. This solid basis is preserved in India.

If Pagans want to become a relevant alternative in the west, they will have to turn to India and acknowledge the valuable knowledge available here. Look at the huge body of profound texts in India. It has no equal anywhere in the world. The attempt to link the Hindu with the Pagan traditions is like linking PH D. students with kindergarten kids.

However, in my view, it would be helpful if Hinduism links up with its offshoots (Buddhism, Jainism and Sikhism) to make the Indian traditions a stronger force that is able to counter the onrush of Christianity and Islam. Both of them want to bring the whole world under their dominion and both of them have an eye on India.

AS: You have lived in India for more than 30 years. What was your first impression of the country?

MW: When I came for the first time, in 1974 during my studies, my impression was not so good. The humidity and heat, the beggar children who would not leave me alone, and so many people everywhere, even though the population then was not even half of what it is today.….and to top it all, I fell sick. When I came home after six weeks, my mother claims I said “Never again India.”

My second visit was due to a friend who convinced me to stop over and see the wildlife sanctuaries in Kerala on my way to Australia. So that trip was meant only as a stopover. And then, in Kanyakumari, I bought Swami Vivekananda’s Jnana Yoga. I was struck by his clarity. Thanks to him I discovered a very different, highly appealing India.

AS: What spiritual Guru (living or historic) have you been most inspired by?

MW: That’s a long story. I wrote a book in German on my time in India that was published in 2006. In short: I felt inspired by many gurus. Swami Vivekananda was the first inspiration.

Soon after, I ended up by chance at the Ardha Kumbh Mela in Haridwar in April 1980 where Sri Anandamayi Ma and Devaraha Baba impressed me a lot. I had this strange feeling that nobody was there behind their eyes. Then I wanted to stay longer in India and wondered how this could be possible. Devaraha Baba gave me his “special” blessing when I told him about my desire. At that time I could have never imagined that, 34 years later, I would still be in India.

For seven years I travelled through the country, and when I wrote down the gurus I had met, 36 names were on that list! I also read a lot, ancient texts and modern sages. Ramana Maharshi’s conversations inspired me a lot. For 12 years I stayed successively with two gurus. Maybe I had not made the best choices, as I left both of them. But ultimately it was for the best. I am now also able to understand the mindset of a devotee of a guru.

AS: What concept(s) in Hindu Dharma do you think is most applicable to the modern world?

MW: The Rishis were concerned with truth and truth is missing in today’s discourse. Truth has to return: especially the knowledge that all is permeated by one conscious Essence. This knowledge is still intuitively there in most Hindus, maybe also in most of those who adopted Christianity or Islam. Yet it is lost in the west.

The analogy of the ocean and the waves illustrates it beautifully: a wave seems to be separate from the ocean. It has its own form and sees only other waves. Yet in its depth, it is one with the ocean, it is ultimately nothing but the ocean. When its form subsides, nothing is lost. Similarly with the individual: It seems separate, but in truth, it is one with the all -pervading consciousness.

To realize this oneness, is the goal of human life according to the Rishis. However, to claim that the human being and the Divine are one is forbidden by Christianity and Islam. It is considered heresy. Mystics who were born in these religions and accidentally discovered and proclaimed this oneness were excommunicated and even killed.

Hindus should reflect on this: what is considered as the highest achievement in Hindu tradition is considered as heresy in the two biggest religions. This means Hinduism differs fundamentally from those dogmatic religions and should not be thrown into the same basket of “religion”.

AS: As a frequent visitor to India, it is shocking for me to observe the population, particularly the youngsters taking so willingly to Western dress and habits. While there is nothing wrong with that; it seems that young people in India do this at the expense of their own traditions.
What do you think the root cause(s) is for this trend?

MW: There seems to be an attempt to make the world conform to the American model. I could observe this in Germany, too. It is far more ‘American’ now than it was when I was a child. Advertisement companies are adept in catching especially students. Peer pressure is doing the rest.

A girl in Jeans and T-shirt once told me that she would like to wear Salwar Kamis, but her friends in college would make fun of her. After this meeting, I wrote on my blog: Jeans in the Indian Summer

However there may be a more sinister agenda than just to make Indians wear western clothing. I can see parallels of what is happening now in India and what happened in the 1960s in Germany. It started with sexually explicit scenes in movies, miniskirts as fashion, a lot of talk about the “generation gap” and women issues. Then came almost daily reports on rapes in newspapers. I remember it, as I was a teenager and didn’t like it when people drew my attention to those reports. Then talk about free sex started and slowly but steadily the family system broke down. Students were in the forefront. When I studied in the 1970s, it was considered old fashioned to marry. Live-in relationships became the norm. There was immense peer pressure to be ‘open and ‘modern’.

I am afraid there are some vested interests who want to break the Indian society as well. India needs to be on its guard.

AS: Do you think that the term Hindutva has been misused by Hindu organizations for narrow political gains, and the actual meaning has been buried?

MW: I don’t feel that Hindutva has been misused for political gains. I have written extensively about Hindutva on my blog. There is no harm when it is in the public sphere. In fact, it should be in the public sphere, as even politics needs to be based on and guided by dharma. This however is not valid for dogmatic religions. They should be kept at a distance from politics, as belief in them is not natural and therefore they try to interfere in the state to keep their followers in check.

AS: Much has been written about the discrimination and unequal treatment that women face in Hindu society.
Do you think that view is substantiated by evidence, given that Hindu Dharma has many texts that elevate and revere woman power (Shakti)?

MW: I feel the negative portrayal of women in Hindu society by the media is very unfair and is part of that agenda to break the strong family system that I mentioned earlier. Hindus easily buy into a feeling of guilt, of being worse than other people. This is simply not true.  I once read that President Obama said the world looks to  USA for ideas. It should look to the Indian tradition instead. While the freedom for women is too directionless in the west and is too restricted in Muslim countries, India has the golden mean. It has the best ideas for a harmonious living together.

Unfortunately, these ideas are being ridiculed even in India by today’s westernised, leftist elite.

AS: What advice would you give to young Hindus who wish to preserve and propagate Hindu Dharma in and outside of India?

MW: Traditionally, three steps are given: Sravana, manana and nididhyasana:
Learn about the truth, reflect deeply on it and then be always aware of it, live it in your life.
You need to have a solid basis in the truth to be able to stand up for it and convey it. This also requires not to tell lies. It is not only an intellectual issue. It is about the highest truth and this truth is living and loving. Become convinced of its Presence through your own experience. Anandamayi Ma advised to be always aware of its presence. “Feel that Bhagwan is acting, walking, thinking, feeling through you. And she added, “You are always in his loving embrace.”

When motivation is pure, guidance will surely come regarding what one should do.


  1. Hello Maria,

    Thanks for sharing your info which has renewed my enthusiasm for reflecting on spiritual matters. There is a lack of interest in spiritual matters in the west……people seem more interested in football !
    We met in shantivanam 32 years ago and again south of Delhi . I visited a holy man ……I think it was Devarahasa with you .




  3. Hello MARIA WIRTH. I humbly request you to create/share a platform with us followers which we can refer to learn about Dharma and Truth.

    1. What do you mean by create/ share a platform? i am not very computer-savy… even this blog happened only because a reader of a Life Positive article installed it for me to put articles which otherwise would not be publishsed or be on the net.

  4. apple_life · · Reply

    Hi Maria,
    It is amazing to see your clarity of thought. as you mentioned about peer pressure to adopt or live alone, it is true i went and frankly still i am going from this phase.

    i want your permission to re blog this article and further article as i will go through.

    1. feel free to reblog, no permission needed.

      1. apple_life · ·

        Thank you. I reblogged this.

  5. apple_life · · Reply

    Reblogged this on ignite the mind and commented:
    before doing and adopting anything just give a thought we as a Indian belongs to great culture. do not fall in trap by media or wrong information about own culture. lets first study our own true scripture or be in contact with a person who has through knowledge. if we fail then time will when we will not get a chance to regret also.

  6. Thank you Maria. It’s shame that our own young people don’t think like that and if they did then the world would be a better place to live in.


    if any of the authors reading this, please read the article above and write abt it , you will be very proud 🙂

  8. chaitanya aggarwal · · Reply

    Hinduism is about humanity as a divine whole.
    Mariaji you are doing a great job in putting across the true meaning and greatness of Hinduism to the westernized urban youngsters of India.
    May Swami Vivekananda give you strength to fulfill your life mission.

  9. Surya,USA · · Reply

    Dear Maria,
    you have expressed your reluctance to blog and I understand where you are coming from. The essence of this communication is to urge you to continue to post and be an western mouthpiece of hindus. Some contemporary wesern hindus have dedicated their lives to nullify the misinformation that was spread in the world. You are in the elite league of Himalayan Academy, Dr.David Frawley, David Knapp, Francois Gautier (he lives in Pune) , Dr.Frank Morales etc. ( readers, please google those names)

    Also please, once in a while, do take up each upanishad and write a commentary on the same. Iam no one to advice you on how to begin and proceed as Iam a student of Upanishads myself. But my research says that western thinkers cherish Katha upanishad most.

    As you eloquently said above, abrahamic belief systems separates god from everything else, and much worse, even god cann’t go near satan or hell to redeem the hapless humans suffering from those two entities. Satan and eternal hell are indispensable doctrinal Achilles heels these faiths cant get rid of (David Frawley). It is debatable why in the first place these 2 entities were created at all. On an aside, I did Deutsch language course in Hyderabad (MaxMueller Bhavan) and travelled to and lived in Hamburg in 90s, I have a fond memories of Deutschland. Power to you Maria. Shanti.



  11. a hindu · · Reply

    you have came to a next level of consciousness, thats why your thought process has cleared.

  12. Dear Maria,

    Since you are way too senior, I offer my ‘Pranaam’. I came to know about you from one of my relative. This post might be somewhat unrelated to the main post but I could not thik of any other way to post this to you. I must tell you that since today morning, I had this lingering thought in my mind – the story of King Daksha and the Self immolation of Sati (Shakti). Considering the fact that matter and energy exist together in harmony. Was the presense of VirBhadra (Matter) and Mahakaali (Energy) in separate form at the event of Sati’s self immolation, a sign of terrible disharmony? what would take to separate matter and energy? and what would be the side effect? the result? Please accept my apology for these barrage of questions without a proper introduction. I am Babylon Bhattacharya from India. I shall eagerly await for your insights.

    1. Dear Babylon,
      Since you are churning these questions in your mind, you will be the best person to get inspiration and intuitive insights to your questions. And not necessarily while you are thinking about it, but when you don’t expect, maybe while waking up…
      For me it makes sense that matter is energy, that ultimately this universe has the quality of a (Shakti’s/ Shiva’s?) dream, yet what makes it appear so solid…?? is it that what HiggsBoson is supposed to solve?

      Did you see my attempt to link India’s wisdom and science and where I feel science could learn from India? (written from a layman’s perspective)
      best wishes

      1. Rathna kumar · ·

        Hi Maria,
        You wrote you have lost faith in christianity at d age of 16. You spent almost your life time to study hindu dharma by beliving and following wrote in a letter to pope ” christians in india are told that hindus go to hell”. We indians are wise enough to taste and see ,study and believe.we are not told by anybody but are gifted to taste d gospel.we being indian christians loosing d total benefits of d government, still alive to believe in d bible.we have a strong faith in jesus.we will never loose faith in christ under any circumstances.There is strong caste system in d people in india but not in hinduism.There may be caste system in people but not in christianity. Pls dont differentiate d religions.if yu speak so caste descrimination is same in two religious found somethinng good in hinduism and raised to criticise christianity.
        Wait for d result.For you and for me there is an end on d earth , judgement, entry into eternity.Then d result .let us see d result.All d religions , all d faiths are leading us to have a hope to enter into heaven. We have a hope , assurance, and d way of life.we belive that christ died on d cross for our sins and rose on d third day ascended into heaven. He is coming again.let us wait for his coming to see d wipe away d faith in jesus in india and from d indian christians. We are wise enough to study d bible to know d truth. We are taught by d spirit of God.we know d truth.

  13. Sir
    I had completed PGDYT from SVYASA UNIVERSITY banglore so can get permanent registration certificate please reply
    Thanking you
    With regards
    Bishen yumnam Imphal-west
    Manipur 795001

    1. sorry, saw it now only, hope you have your registration meanwhile. i would not know how to get it.

  14. Namaste,
    AS, looks to be some Communist Terror Stuff, always in Attacking Mode on Hinduism, HIndutva

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: