Letter to Savio Rodrigues in response to his perplexing tweet

Dear Savio,

I had the pleasure to meet you at a conference and you came across as likeable and intelligent. And I felt, we had in common that we both grew up as Christians but realized that Hindu or Sanatana Dharma is the better option.

That’s why I was surprised by your tweet:

“I am a Christian by my faith but Hindu by my roots. That’s me. You cannot accept this fact about me, then it is your problem, not mine.”

Most Hindus don’t know the essence of the Christian faith, and you may have thought you get away with this? Or maybe you yourself don’t know the essence??

Here it is in short:

The essence of Christianity is that Christians have the right faith and will be saved and Hindus have the wrong faith and will be damned forever.  And from this follows that missionaries who dedicate their lives to save Hindu souls by getting them baptized, are doing a great job.

You would know about the claim “There is no salvation outside of the Church”. However, hopefully, you won’t take it seriously and for you “Christian faith” may basically mean seeing Jesus Christ as your guide and object of devotion, as Hindus are devoted to  Krishna, Ram, Shiva, Devi….

To feel devotion for Jesus is of course fine. No Hindu has any objection. They would see you as belonging to Sanatana Dharma, which accepts many different ways to connect with the ultimate Cause of our existence, whom the Vedas call Brahman or Tat. But to declare devotion for Jesus as “Christian faith” is not honest, because it’s not true. Other conditions apply.

You would know that, as a Christian, you don’t have the option to pick and choose. You have to accept the whole doctrine of the “faith” which you may have repeated in Sunday mass umpteen times, and this doctrine postulates the exclusivity of the ‘one Lord Jesus Christ, the only son of God…. For us men and our salvation, he came down from heaven…” (Nicene Creed)

So you owe an explanation to Hindus what you mean by “I am Christian by my faith”.

If an amiable and influential person like you stands openly by his Christian faith, it will confirm Hindus in their belief, that all religions are the same, and it’s only people who misunderstand their religion, who give trouble to Hindus and not certain tenets of the religion itself.

Yet the problem is precisely with the doctrine that “there is no salvation outside of the Church”.

Please do clarify in a public post, whether you agree with this crucial tenet that there is no salvation outside of the Church and that, by extension, missionaries do a good job.

Most missionaries really believe that they do a great job.

I am sure, you don’t believe it. But please…. say it openly. You owe it to Hindus.

And hopefully you won’t mind my plain speak…

Regards

Maria Wirth

2 comments

  1. The truth is the bible is not a revelation.

    “Revelation is a communication of something, which the person to whom the thing is revealed did not know before. For if I have done a thing, or seen it done, it needs no revelation to tell me, I have done or seen it done nor enable me to tell it or write it. Revelation, therefore, cannot be applied to anything done upon earth, of which man is himself actor or witness and consequently all the historical part of the bible which is almost the whole of it, is not within the meaning and compass of the word revelation and therefore is not the word of god.” Thomas Paine
    vjsingh.info/christ

  2. Saam John chandy · · Reply

    Maria wirth
    Well a beautiful crafted letter to try and prove Jesus Christ son of God saviour same asextreme Muslim who believe in Allah are Kaffirs must die the one who eliminates kafir will get heaven & 72 virgins.
    Similarly those pastors who are converting will go to heaven, such childish relegion marketing and kids deprived of true and broad viaion fall for this dogma.
    Unlike sanatan dharma encompassing all in the world 🙏

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: